School Improvement Is a Systems Problem
“Our PLCs are a waste of time.”

If you’re a principal hearing that from teachers, your first instinct might be to tighten the agenda, introduce a new protocol, or remind everyone why professional learning communities matter. Before you do, ask what teachers have experienced in those meetings that makes the complaint ring true.
Maybe they spend most of the meeting reporting scores and leave without a plan for what to teach next. Maybe they rarely get an uninterrupted block of time. Or maybe they’ve learned that bringing in work students struggled with feels like admitting they did something wrong.
In our last post, I wrote about the principal’s role as chief storyteller. The stories people tell about their school reveal something about its culture and shape what people believe is possible. But those stories come from somewhere. If teachers repeatedly leave their PLC without anything they can use in tomorrow’s lesson, they have good reason to question the value of the meeting.
Good leaders help teams improve how they work together. Great leaders examine what keeps getting in the way of that work and change the conditions teams need to succeed.
Look at what the system makes possible
In my doctoral research, I explored the thinking behind effective school leadership, including how principals solve problems and use what they know about their schools. One implication for school improvement is that the same visible problem can call for different leadership actions. A team that keeps losing its planning time needs something different from a team that meets every week but feels uncomfortable examining student work together.
When the same problem keeps appearing across classrooms or teams, leaders have reason to look beyond individual performance. The pattern may point to something in the school's routines, expectations, or working conditions that makes the problem likely to recur.
Research on school improvement supports examining these organizational conditions. Bryk and colleagues' work on school organizational supports, for example, highlights how improvement depends on the interaction of leadership, professional capacity, relationships, instructional guidance, and the learning environment.
At Compass Edvantage, we examine six research-informed conditions that can shape a school's improvement efforts:
A safe, orderly, functional environment
Relational trust
Collaborative culture and structures
Quality classroom instruction
Collective teacher efficacy
Academic press, or a shared expectation that students will do challenging work and receive the support to succeed
These are not six independent levers or an exhaustive list of everything that matters. They interact, and some are both influenced by school conditions and important influences on what happens next.
Consider how just two of those conditions interact. A principal can protect an hour every Wednesday and give teachers a predictable place to work together. Whether teachers use that hour to examine where students got stuck may depend on how much they trust one another. If they expect the conversation to turn into a judgment of their teaching, they may stick to sharing scores and materials. From the hallway, it looks like the PLC is running as planned. The conversation teachers need to have is still missing.
Of course, time and trust alone do not guarantee a productive conversation. Teachers also need the instructional knowledge and skills to interpret student work and decide what to do next. Organizational conditions make effective practice more possible; they do not replace the expertise required to carry it out.
That's what systems thinking adds to school improvement. It helps leaders see how the conditions around a practice shape what people can do with it.
Turn the diagnosis into a leadership move
This is where Leadership Enactment comes in. A school improvement plan might say, “Strengthen PLCs to improve instruction.” The principal still has to decide what to change in the way teachers work together and how to tell whether that change is helping.
Three questions can guide that decision.
What pattern are we seeing? Listen to teachers and look at what teams routinely do. What do they bring to meetings? What decisions do they leave with? What happens in classrooms afterward?
What conditions might be producing that pattern? Ask what makes the current routine easy to repeat. If the standing agenda is built around reporting scores, how much time does it leave for teachers to work out why students struggled or what to do next?
What can we change, and what will we look for? Pick a condition you can influence. Decide what you would expect to see in teachers’ practice and in student work if the change helps.
Suppose the principal learns that one grade-level team spends most of its PLC time reporting scores. She works with the team to redesign its next two meetings. At the first meeting, teachers bring student responses to a common math task. Looking across classrooms, they notice that students can give a correct answer but struggle to explain their reasoning. The teachers agree to model two ways to explain a solution and give students another opportunity to try it. At the second meeting, they bring fresh work and look at where the explanations improved and where students still need support.
The principal can learn something from both meetings. Did the team leave with a teaching decision it could use? Did the next round of work show a change in how students explained their thinking? Those questions help the principal see whether the meeting is serving its instructional purpose.
The work does not end with redesigning the meeting. The principal continues to examine what teachers are able to do, what support they need, and whether the change is producing better opportunities for students to learn. That cycle of observing, learning, and adjusting is how a leadership decision becomes an improvement process.
Help one team's story travel
Imagine that, after a few rounds, the teachers begin to talk differently about their PLC. When a colleague asks how the meeting went, one of them says, “We figured out where students were getting stuck, tried something, and came back to see if it helped.”
That's a different story, grounded in an experience the teachers had together. And it may still be the story of only one team. Across the hall, another team may be spending its Wednesday meetings the way it always has.
The principal can help the story travel by giving the team a chance to tell it. At a faculty meeting, the teachers could show what they used to spend their time on, how they changed the meeting, and what they saw in the next round of student work. They could also talk about what took a few tries to get right. That detail matters to colleagues who are wondering whether they could do something similar with their own team.
One team might borrow the idea of bringing fresh student work back to the next meeting. Another might realize it first needs a common task worth discussing. The principal can listen for what each team needs and help create the conditions for it to try.
But sharing a successful team's story is not the same as changing the school's system. If other teams lack protected time, effective facilitation, or the instructional support needed to use student work well, hearing about one team's success may not be enough. The principal has to consider which conditions need to change across the school and which supports should be adapted to each team's needs.
As more teams have experiences worth sharing, the school has more evidence of what productive collaboration can look like. The goal is not to replicate one team's meeting. It is to build the conditions that allow productive collaboration to become a regular part of how the school works.
Application Reflection
Pick one improvement priority where you keep seeing the same problem across classrooms or teams. Choose one schoolwide routine or decision that might be contributing to it. You could examine what the master schedule actually protects, what your data meetings ask teachers to do, or what happens after teachers receive instructional feedback.
What would you look at this week to see whether that part of the system is helping people do what you expect? Start with one piece of evidence, such as two teams' agendas and follow-up notes, and ask the people who use the routine where it helps and where they get stuck.
Continue Exploring
The Principal as Chief Storyteller — Explore how the stories educators tell about their schools influence what they believe is possible and how leaders can help those stories change.
Why the Plan Is Not Enough — Examine the difference between developing an improvement plan and creating the conditions for meaningful implementation.
Interested in practical, research-informed perspectives on school leadership and improvement? Subscribe to Compass Edvantage to receive new articles and ideas for leading improvement differently.
Bryk, A. S., Sebring, P. B., Allensworth, E., Luppescu, S., & Easton, J. Q. (2010). Organizing Schools for Improvement: Lessons from Chicago. University of Chicago Press.




Comments